newfangled research finds that blue atomic number 1 , vaunt by fossil fuel producers as a climate resolution , actually has a 20 % larger glasshouse gas footmark than just using lifelike flatulence . Thestudy , publish Thursday in Energy Science & Engineering , gives some of import context on a much - hyped unexampled fuel , one that bechance to be the“clean energy ” orchard apple tree of the fossil fuel industry ’s oculus .
Hydrogen , the most vernacular element in the universe , hasa lot of promise for the push transition : it can power cars , cater electricity to buildings , and be used to aid decarbonize tough industry like manufacture and building . The trouble with hydrogen is that it require to be separate from other elements , which in and of itself take a lot of energy . Hydrogen can be separated from oxygen in water via electrolysis to create what ’s known as green H — an option free from any greenhouse petrol emissions , but one that ’s pretty expensive . It can also be harvested from fossil fuel like coal and gas , to make what ’s recognize as gray hydrogen . This is a slight cheaper than unripe H , but emits quite a circumstances of CO2 during the atomic number 1 extraction physical process .
Faced with growing call to decarbonize — as well as a large supply of natural petrol that they needed to regain uses for — fossil fuel producer come up with the melodic theme of repackaging the figure of speech of grey atomic number 1 as low - carbon by becharm all the carbon emissions that would come with its creation . A raw case of H was born : blue H , which is gray atomic number 1 that uses carbon capture and storage technology to get disembarrass of all those pesky carbon emissions and be , technically , a lower - carbon fuel . Big Oilsaw the opportunityto use gamey hydrogen as part of their public relations crowd for a lower - carbon future tense .
Toyota’s hydrogen fuel cell truck.Photo: Jae C. Hong (AP)
“ As far as I can tell , no one was talking about blue hydrogen until just a few class ago , ” cogitation writer Robert Howarth said in an electronic mail . “ The Hydrogen Council was established in 2017 by BP , Shell , and Total , and they and other industry - refer groups bulge out crowd this blue hydrogen mind hard . They described [ blue-blooded hydrogen ] as low emissions , or sometimes zero emissions . But they never presented genuine data to back that up . ” Until this paper , Howarth said , there has n’t been any compeer - brush up attempt to psychoanalyse the nursery gas footprint of aristocratic hydrogen — just “ industry summaries ” that he say “ do not hold up well to close scrutiny . ”
Unfortunately for the rock oil and gas industry , closely look at the creation process of blue hydrogen uncovers some uncomfortable the true . Howarth ’s study found that profane hydrogen has only a slenderly lower carbon footprint than grizzly hydrogen — and , in terms of methane , the picture is a lot worse .
“ While CO2 discharge are less for gloomy than for gray H , methane emissions are gravid , ” Howarth said . “ That is because more lifelike gas is ware to make the grim hydrogen , as energy is take to power the CO2 seizure , and this energy comes from natural gas . ”
Methane emission only stay in the atmosphere for a little over a decade , far forgetful than carbon copy dioxide ’s 300 - to-1,000 - year lifetime — but they backpack quite a punch while they ’re there , as methane is around 80 times more potent than carbon dioxide . The IPCC reputation released this weekfor the first time prognosticate out methane as a big clime problem , witness that methane emanation have arise drastically over the past decennary . main among the methane culprits are vegetable oil and gun companies , which free a bunch of methane in the process of pull up natural gun . The IPCC estimates that fogy fuel companies were responsible for a quarter of ball-shaped methane emissions .
The methane findings in the IPCC report are peculiarly distressful when considering what a instinctive - accelerator pedal - heavy process creating hydrogen from fogy fuel and storing the CO2 emissions is . In fact , make the hydrogen is so vim - intensive that blue hydrogen ’s greenhouse accelerator pedal footprint is full-grown than that of innate throttle . In other intelligence , burning this suppose “ clean ” fuel actually is worse , nursery gas - wise , than just using instinctive gas itself .
“ It accept a declamatory amount of lifelike gas to make hydrogen , using the methane in the gas as the feedstock source , but also to burn it to power the steam - reform process and the CO2 capture process , ” Howarth said . “ There are discharge of both CO2 and methane associate with this orotund usage of gasolene . ”
There ’s a muckle of plug around the possibilities of atomic number 1 right now , as governments and industries around the human race look to decarburise . The infrastructure bill that passed the Senate Wednesday included $ 8 billionearmarked for hydrogen muscularity development ; Department of Energy functionary havetalked in the pastabout how blue hydrogen can fit into the Biden governance ’s clean energy goals . The atomic number 1 industry say in February thatmore than 30 countrieshave created plans around developing more atomic number 1 projects . The UK is developing a atomic number 1 scheme of its own , and a government functionary narrate the Guardian thathydrogen would be “ essential ” to the UK ’s own climate goals .
“ We need to move out from all fossil fuels as soon as potential , ” Howarth pronounce . “ The best way to do that is with 100 % renewable electricity from solar , flatus , and hydro sources , combined with beneficial electrification to furnish heating system from high - efficiency heat pumps and to provide conveyance from galvanising vehicles . juicy H is a dangerous distraction , which , if actually employed at plate , would aggravate rather than help address clime modification . insurance policy Almighty should be skeptical of such idea until they are soundly vetted by self-governing full lifecycle analysis by scientists and engineers in a transparent and match - reviewed framework . ”
ChemistryFuel gasHydrogenIndustrial gasesPhysical sciencesShell
Daily Newsletter
Get the best tech , skill , and cultivation news in your inbox day by day .
newsworthiness from the future , delivered to your nowadays .
You May Also Like
